Credit, Sebastián Vivallo Oñate/Agencia Makro/Getty Images
"The final straw in a process of exposing vulnerable people on social media."
This is how lawyer Luciana Dadalto classifies the episode involving former president Fernando Henrique Cardoso, 95 years old. Last week, a video published on social media exposed images of the former president, diagnosed with Alzheimer's, and the apartment where he lives in São Paulo.
In the video, presented and published by Wesley Oliveira, 34 years old, he shows signed furniture and paintings, says the street where the former president lives and shows images of the room where he supposedly sleeps.
The images circulated amid indignant comments and questions about who had consented to such exposure. FHC was banned by the courts this year, at the request of his children, due to the worsening of the disease.
But Dadalto, who is also a researcher on topics linked to autonomy and dignity at the end of life, says that, despite the outrage over a case linked to a public figure, stories like this are told every day.
"When we see a situation as absurd as this, the exposure of a former president in a situation of intense vulnerability, it comes as a shock," he says. "But, in reality, the networks are full of posts made by people who, theoretically, should protect these vulnerable people: schools, health professionals, caregivers..."
On Tuesday (11/10), the São Paulo Civil Police indicted Wesley Oliveira and his partner, Lessandro Gonçalves, for defamation and discrimination against elderly people.
The prosecution made use of the article of the Statute of the Elderly, which establishes that it is a crime to display or convey, through any means of communication, derogatory or insulting information or images. The penalty may include imprisonment for up to three years and a fine.
End of Most read
The case gained repercussion because it concerns a public figure, but the expert warns that such behavior is commonplace and is already naturalized.
"How many times have we seen videos of patients in a highly vulnerable situation? On commemorative dates, this is very common; they put birthday hats and Santa Claus hats on elderly patients or paint children as bunny rabbits at Easter. We are talking about the same thing, to a greater or lesser extent."
End of content
Watch news from Brazil and the world on the BBC World Service
Download here
End of app promotion
Wesley Oliveira told BBC News Brasil, before the police operation, that his objective with the video was to show that people with dementia can participate in meetings and appear in photos and videos.
He stated that he received authorization from Patrícia Kundrat, wife of the former president, to record and publish the material. Patrícia, who has been with FHC since 2010, denied having authorized the recording.
According to a report published by the newspaper Folha de S. Paulo, Patrícia said she authorized Wesley to enter the apartment, but not to film or publish the images.
She told the police that the video was recorded in a moment of distraction and accused Wesley of exposing the former president.
Patrícia filed a police report and FHC's children asked the São Paulo Public Ministry for a criminal investigation.
But Dadalto claims that who authorized the entry and recordings should not be in dispute. “We are starting from the wrong place,” he says.
"The right to image and privacy belongs to the person. No curator or legal representative has the right to give up the privacy or image of that other person."
For her, this is an illegal situation and those responsible must answer for it. "We are talking about an illicit situation, a violation of personality rights, of fundamental rights."
However, it raises another question.
"Assuming there is a conviction, who will receive eventual compensation? It's the family. But the damage has already been caused and there is no criminal or civil justice or any other way that can repair this damage."
"If the person doesn't know what happened, can we do anything?" he asks.
'Naturalized violations' and the living will
The case involving the former president exposed his exposure, but Dadalto explains that there are other situations that can be classified as violations and that do not necessarily involve images.
"How many people have we seen talking about their parents' illnesses, especially in the case of dementia?", he says. She states that writing books, telling stories, publishing previously unauthorized reports are also forms of violation.
"But we have taken it for granted that children or the people they care for can expose the lives of the people being cared for."
The specialist is one of the biggest voices in defense of the living will, also known as advance directives. His book — Testament Vital (Editora Foco) — is now in its seventh edition.
It is a document through which a lucid person, with the ability to make decisions, records their positive and negative wishes — that is, what they want and what they don't want — with regard to healthcare in irreversible situations.
The document only becomes valid when the author loses decision-making capacity. And in addition to procedures and care, the living will may also contain — or not — authorization to use an image or the story itself, according to the lawyer.
"In my living will I put this clause: I do not authorize anyone to publish anything on social media, nor to use my image or my illness", she explains.
"But this is much more moral than legal. If someone ends up publishing something, the damage has already been caused", he points out. "The person can even respond legally, but that's it."
She cites as an example the development of the case involving FHC. Wesley Oliveira's social media account was suspended, but the video had already circulated and people could have downloaded and archived this material. “The damage is done”, he summarizes.
In other words, any compensation received by the family in such a case would have a much more moral character than containing the damage itself.
For her, there is no shortage of laws to protect people in vulnerable situations. "There is no lack of law. But, unfortunately, the law does not solve it", he says, mentioning the Elderly Statute, the General Data Protection Law, the Civil Code and the Constitution.
For her, society lacks maturity in relation to illness and vulnerability. "A person who cannot speak out remains a person. They continue to have rights," he says.
Credit, Personal archive/Luciana Dadalto
Is it possible to grow old in peace?
In an interview with BBC News Brasil, Wesley Oliveira stated that he saw no reason to worry about the investigation. "I took a selfie with him inside his house, where I was a guest," he told the reporter. "About the police, for me there is no reason to worry, because there is no crime."
But Wesley's tranquility comes into conflict with the law. According to the Civil Code, "the private life of a natural person is inviolable". It is also provided that, "with the exception of cases provided for by law, personality rights are non-transferable and non-renounceable".
The Elderly Statute states that "the right to respect consists of the inviolability of physical, mental and moral integrity, encompassing the preservation of image, identity, autonomy, values, ideas and beliefs, spaces and personal objects".
Therefore, Dadalto defends that the debate be put on the table, since legally there are resources that should guarantee protection and not call into question the right to aging with dignity.
"It is possible to grow old in peace in a society that protects us. But it is important to say that it is not about aging; it is aging plus illness", he states.
"The question I think is: can you get sick in peace in a world where everything is exposed? I have doubts today, but we need to start this debate", says Dadalto.
Credit, Getty Images
According to Wesley, her husband, Lessandro, has been friends with Patrícia Kundrat for more than 30 years and they met at church. Wesley says that Lessandro is also a friend of FHC, and it was through him that he began to frequent the former president's house.
"I always went to his house, because Lessandro went there and I went with him", he told the reporter. Wesley stated that the coexistence also brought him closer to Patrícia, and that there were many visits.
The influencer, as he defined himself on social media, said he asked Patrícia for permission to record while the three talked and drank in the apartment. According to him, the former president's wife agreed to the recording and publication, without establishing restrictions on the rooms or images that could be shown.
He told the reporter that the images were taken on different days, during recent visits, and that the scene in which he appears alongside FHC was recorded during the World Cup. Wesley also said that he watched the video with Patrícia before the repercussions.
The version contradicts the report that Patrícia presented to the police. Asked about proof of authorization, Wesley said that the conversation took place during the visit and that he did not think about recording it.
“She says she didn’t authorize it and I say she authorized it,” he told the reporter.
But according to Dadalto, it doesn't matter whether there was authorization or not. "Even if the wife had authorized it, or the son, who is the trustee, we are talking about an illicit situation, a violation of personality rights, of fundamental rights", he says.
"That's why I say it's the last straw from a glass that was filling. We have to take a step back and think from an ethical and moral point of view: what society is this that has dealt with these situations routinely and finds this type of exposure common?"
*With additional reporting by Luiz Fernando Toledo, from BBC News Brasil in London
Discover more
Watch
End of Watch




