Mexico City – The Government of Claudia Sheinbaum has mobilized the political and governmental apparatus to challenge the conclusions of a UN committee, which escalated the crisis of more than 133,000 missing people in Mexico to the General Assembly. The dispute does not revolve around the facts, which neither party denies, but rather over how to name them and, consequently, over who bears responsibility.

First modification: 04/12/2026 - 22:27

To display this YouTube content, you must allow advertising and audience measurement cookies.

An extension on your browser appears to be blocking the video player from loading. In order to view this content, you must disable it on this site.

The Government of Mexico and the UN entered a new point of friction after the decision of the Committee against Forced Disappearances (CED) to bring the Mexican case to the General Assembly, in the midst of what the organization itself describes as a persistent crisis regarding disappearances.

The CED report builds its diagnosis on a decade of information, with a starting point in 2012, and validates its findings with the field work carried out during its visit to Mexico in 2021. Its conclusion: "Well-founded indications" that forced disappearances in the country operate as a widespread and systematic phenomenon, with elements that could constitute crimes against humanity, in many cases with the direct participation or "acquiescence" of authorities at different levels of government (i.e. that is, the tolerance or omission of the State in the face of patterns of disappearances, even having contextual knowledge of them).

The analysis places the worsening of the phenomenon in the context of the "war on drug trafficking" that began in 2006 (in the government of conservative Felipe Calderón), and registers a recent sustained rebound: between 2023 and 2025 alone, 28,880 new disappearances were recorded. Added to this figure is a collapsed forensic scenario, with more than 72,000 unidentified bodies and the proliferation of clandestine graves, indicators that, for this UN committee, reinforce the existence of structural patterns of impunity.

The official reaction was immediate. The document was described as “tendentious”, lacking “legal rigor”, “partial” and “biased”, by the Mexican Government, in a frontal rejection that reveals both a semantic dispute and a fundamental disagreement about the nature of the crisis.

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs (SRE, Chancellery), the Ministry of the Interior (Ministry of the Interior), the Government of Mexico City, the ruling Morena party (left) and President Claudia Sheinbaum herself, among another dozen political actors related to the Government, rejected the report, arguing that it ignores progress since 2019 and focuses on past periods (2009-2017). They argue that Mexico "does not tolerate, allow or order" these disappearances and that the procedure does not reflect current reality.

To display this content from X (Twitter), you must allow audience measurement and advertising cookies.

The newly appointed head of Foreign Relations of Mexico, Roberto Velasco Álvarez, stressed: "What we are questioning are some characterizations and some issues in the report that seem to us to be an overreach by the committee."

Read alsoPresident of Mexico says that the UN committee ignored her government's achievements in human rights. HH.

What the Law says

From the perspective of International Law, the CED decision is not a ruling—the committee is not a court—but neither does it constitute a mere academic opinion. This is a technical determination with "immense interpretive and evidentiary weight", based on information provided by the Mexican State itself, victims, civil society organizations and NGOs, explains expert Moisés Montiel.

The triggered mechanism—Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance—operates when the committee identifies “well-founded indications” of systematic or widespread patterns. "It is not binding in the sense that it forces the State to do A, B, C and D," clarifies Montiel, "but it does imply that the issue has reached a higher threshold of concern."

This legal nuance clashes with the government narrative. While Sheinbaum denounces a "political background" behind the CED's decision, the International Law expert emphasizes that the committee "is the authorized interpreter of the convention": its competence to evaluate Mexico's compliance derives from the treaty that the country voluntarily ratified. The tension, he says, does not lie in an overreach of the organism, but in two readings of the same reality.

Read alsoSheinbaum accuses UN experts of human rights. HH. to "criticize" Mexico without foundation

The debate on tolerance

In the young history of the committee, whose convention only came into force in 2010, this is the first time it has activated the article against a State.

The concept that generates the most friction is that of "acquiescence" or "tolerance." For the CED, it is not necessary for state agents to directly carry out disappearances for international responsibility to exist. It is enough for the State, being aware of recurring patterns, to fail to adopt effective measures to prevent them, investigate them or locate the victims, Montiel details.

Under this logic, he comments, cases such as the discovery of Rancho Izaguirre, in Teuchitlán (Jalisco), discovered by the Guerreros Buscadores de Jalisco collective in March 2025,—where local authorities could have had prior information—configure indications of institutional tolerance of that referred to by the CED.

“If we were not acting, if we were folding our arms, if we did not care about a situation like this, if we did not accompany the victims, if we had not done anything... but why is there no recognition from this Committee of experts of what the Government of Mexico has done?” Sheinbaum questioned during his daily press conference on April 7.

For Carlos López Buburrón, researcher at the public university Colegio de México, "although there are no elements that the Mexican State or federal authorities are actively ordering people to disappear, there are elements that show that there are individuals, criminal organizations that disappear people and systematically the authority knows that this is happening and generally decides not to do anything or is not doing enough."

"Mexico has a serious situation of disappearance, both forced and committed by individuals. And, although there are efforts, the situation is still very extensive and there is no prevention and eradication policy," says López Buburrón. According to him, "Mexico has exemplary legislation on the matter, but it is legislation that has not advanced, that in reality is not operating."

Regarding the figures, López Buburrón validates the report's data—more than 130,000 missing people, 72,000 unidentified remains—and adds a critical nuance to the government narrative: disappearance is a "continuous crime" that does not end until the person appears, so attributing the cases to previous Administrations "does not exempt the Mexican State from its obligation to respond."

In a recent review of official records, the Government of Claudia Sheinbaum concluded that only 43,128 cases—approximately a third of the total—correspond to people who are actually missing. The rest are names of people who became active again after being reported or who were entered with so little information that it is impossible to search for them. Based on this, Sheinbaum criticizes the CED report, ensuring that its conclusions are supported in very few cases, from only four states and from periods before his party, Morena, came to power in 2018.

In an interview in local media, lawyer Santiago Corcuera, who was a member of the UN Working Group on Forced Disappearances from 2004 to 2010, commented that "the committee's decision has already been made. There is no way to appeal or appeal it."

When asked about the reaction to the decision, he commented: "I wish that (the Government) could abandon the first very aggressive attitude contained in the statement. Abandon this unproductive and useless situation of arguing with a United Nations committee on questions of legal interpretation or interpretations of factual situations."

Read alsoThe drama of disappearances in Mexico: what happened at Rancho Izaguirre?

From the technical to the political: the jump to the General Assembly

The activation of article 34 moves the debate from a technical space to an eminently political one. The UN General Assembly, the highest deliberative body of the multilateral system, does not issue rulings or impose sanctions, but its resolutions have considerable reputational weight.

"You leave technical logic and enter political logic," Montiel warns. In this scenario, diplomatic alliances and ideological sympathies can have more influence than legal arguments. States with close relations with Mexico could support the government's position, regardless of the technical soundness of the committee's findings.

For López Buburrón, this milestone represents a triumph of citizen advocacy, but also a warning: "It is not the panacea, it is another way, perhaps one of the last ones available to solve a crisis of this size."

Montiel warns that the risk of this politicization is that the debate deviates from its original purpose: the protection of victims. “The most terrible thing about all this, that the response that the Mexican government has given is that the government is defending itself and the truth in all this, shooting the messenger, delegitimizing the Committee, the question is, and where are the victims?”, he asserted.

Read alsoThe Mexican Government turns against the UN due to the crisis of forced disappearances

Related keywords

The content you requested does not exist or is no longer available.