Credit, Paulo Pinto/Agência Brasil
The government of President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva (PT) is denying, via the Access to Information Law (LAI), the publication of studies, opinions and reports that supported the publication of two of the main measures of the PT member's so-called "goodness" package on the eve of the presidential elections: the provisional measures that created Desenrola 3.0 and the one that prohibited the operation of fixed-odd betting houses (bets) in Brazil.
Because they were launched on the eve of the elections and foresee possible costs to the public coffers, the measures were classified by the opposition to Lula as part of a so-called "package of kindness" and criticized for being supposedly voter-friendly.
The decree that regulates the LAI, from 2011, provides for access to preparatory documents used by the government after the decision-making process that precedes, for example, the issuance of laws, provisional measures, among other acts.
In response to two requests via LAI made by BBC News Brasil, the Civil House claimed that the documents were protected by "lawyer-client" confidentiality, since they were used in the government's legal advice and, therefore, could not be disclosed.
In previous years, however, BBC News Brasil gained access to preparatory documents that gave rise to acts such as decrees signed by the then president.
Experts interviewed by BBC News Brasil, however, say that the argument creates a type of "eternal secrecy" for documents and classify the measure as illegal.
"What is being done creates eternal secrecy. We will never know, for example, what technical reasons caused the government to ban betting, and this creates space for rumors and misinformation", says the co-founder and advocacy director of the non-governmental organization Ficam Sabendo, Bruno Morassutti.
When contacted, Palácio do Planalto did not respond to questions sent by BBC News Brasil. In a statement, the Civil House defended the secrecy of the documents.
End of Most read
"Access to legal statements is protected by professional secrecy and arises from legal guarantees applicable to the practice of law, including within the scope of public administration. The professional secrecy of public lawyers, applied in these and all other cases, is based on the Law Statute", said the ministry in the note to the report.
Credit, Getty Images
Requests denied
Watch news from Brazil and the world on the BBC World Service
Download here
End of app promotion
On September 25, the federal government announced the launch of the Desenrola 3.0 program and the nationwide ban on betting operations.
Both were done through provisional measures that came into force immediately and were sent to the National Congress to be voted on.
At the time, Lula was facing a fierce dispute in the first round of elections against the senator and then presidential candidate Flávio Bolsonaro (PL-RJ) and encountered resistance from part of the electorate due to the high level of family debt attributed to high interest rates and debts with bets.
On September 25th and 28th, shortly after the government's announcement, BBC News Brasil requested access to the preparatory documents that gave rise to the two measures.
These documents function as a kind of "official trail" of the government's decision-making process. Normally, they are grouped in an administrative process that is processed in the Electronic Information System (SEI).
In this process, the various bodies that advise the President of the Republic publish reports, estimates, studies and legal opinions that indicate what led the government to go in a certain direction, whether any body advised a decision in the opposite direction or what risks were highlighted throughout the process.
Article no. 20 of decree 7,724 of 2012, which regulates the LAI, provides for the disclosure of these documents after the decision is taken.
"Access to a preparatory document or information contained therein, used as a basis for decision-making or administrative acts, will be ensured as soon as the act or decision is published", says the decree.
On October 29, the Civil House, however, denied the requests with a similar argument.
"The legal opinions produced within the scope of the Attorney General's Office and the legal advice of the Presidency of the Republic are protected by attorney-client privilege (...) the other documents that make up the administrative process were sent to this Special Secretariat for Legal Affairs of the Civil House of the Presidency of the Republic to support the preparation of the relevant legal statement and, in this condition, they are covered by the same protection regime applicable to the legal advice provided", said the response sent by the Civil House.
The ministry also argued that the documents used in the edition of the two MPs should remain confidential based on the Law Statute, which provides that communications and documents exchanged in the legal guidance process must be protected.
Without the disclosure of the documents that supported the two MPs, it is not possible to know when the government officially began studying the measure, what guidance was given by the technical and legal consultants of the departments involved or if there was any type of warning about possible negative impacts.
The Desenrola 3.0 program, for example, provides for the federal government to purchase credit portfolios from financial institutions that have defaulting customers. After this purchase, made by auction, the government will be able to grant discounts of up to 90% on the debt values.
"People used to have to look for a bank. Now, the government will buy people's debt," said Lula during the launch of the program.
At the press conference held on the day of the launch, the Minister of Planning and Management, Bruno Moretti, estimated that the impact of Desenrola 3.0 on public accounts could reach R$15 billion by 2028.
In the interview, however, no documents and technical studies were disclosed about the possible negative impacts of the measure or even whether it had undergone any prior efficiency assessment.
The same happens with the ban on betting. Without the disclosure of the MP's preparatory documents, it is not possible to know when the government began studying this possibility, which bodies were in favor or against it and what risks were highlighted in relation to the impacts of the measure after three years of measures taken in the opposite direction, to regulate the gaming and betting sector.
"I made the decision to take the necessary hard and drastic measure. It's like cancer, either remove the tumor, or the tumor will kill us. (...) It was a lot of fighting, it was a lot of discussion, it was a lot of let's do this, do everything, do nothing, do it halfway, no. Since we have to do it, let's do what has to be done. End the bets", said Lula at the launch of the MP.
Despite this, associations representing companies that explore the fixed-odd betting market (bets) criticized the measure, alleging, among other things, that the government had not considered that the ban could encourage the illegal betting market and the possible negative impact on public accounts due to the reduction in expected tax revenue.
In the days following the measure, companies in the sector warned that they would sue the Judiciary to recover the R$2.5 billion paid in grants to the federal government to be able to operate in the country.
For Bruno Morassutti, from Ficam Sabendo, the secrecy claimed by the government regarding these documents is an error.
"This understanding began under Michel Temer's government, was maintained under Jair Bolsonaro's government and is now recovered under the Lula government. It is an argument criticized by civil society, because it prevents people from knowing what led a President of the Republic to sanction a law or send a project to Congress", he says.
Morassutti says that the government's decision creates "eternal secrecy" over the documents because, in practice, there is no deadline for the government to review this position or for this secrecy to expire, as normally happens with other types of official documents.
The LAI provides four deadlines for secrecy of documents or information: 5 years for reserved documents; 15 years for secret degree; 25 for top secret and up to 100 years for documents or personal information related to someone's intimacy, private life, honor and image.
According to him, legal advice provided by public lawyers to the government should not be equated with confidentiality between client and lawyer in the private sphere.
"The legal profession does not have the right to specific secrecy when we talk about public law. In private law, yes. It is related to the right to defense. If this understanding prevails, we will never know what basis the government had for deciding to put an end to betting, for example."
The program director of the non-governmental organization Transparência Brasil, Marina Atoji, also criticizes the secrecy imposed by the government on the documents of the two MPs.
"(This understanding) is an aberration. They are documents produced by public lawyers in the exercise of their function, which is to serve the public interest of society. The application of this secrecy in this context should not be permissible. It can be said that this measure opens a breach, yes, for eternal secrecy", says Atoji.
Lula promised to reduce secrecy
The position of the Civil House, subordinate to the Presidency of the Republic, goes partially against what Lula has publicly defended since the 2022 elections, when he ran for and won against then-president Jair Bolsonaro (PL).
At the time, he promised that he would end the 100-year-old secrecy imposed by his opponent's government on documents and information requested via LAI.
"Anything is a 100-year secrecy. If I win, I will end this secrecy. This has to be investigated. If he is honest as he says, he should not be afraid," said Lula in September 2022, in the middle of the campaign for his third term.
Four years later, during this year's re-election campaign, Lula said, again, that he was against the imposition of secrecy in his government.
"If a journalist asks for information and the person in charge denies it, ask me, and I will tell you. Because there is nothing in this world that deserves to be kept confidential", said the PT member in July this year during an interview with the program Podcast Intelligence Ltda.
In a note sent to BBC News Brasil, however, the Civil House maintained its position on the secrecy of the documents.
"This protection can apply to the procedures for drafting and analyzing different normative and administrative acts, including provisional measures, bills, sanctions and presidential vetoes. Its objective is to ensure the confidentiality of communications and legal guidance in the regular exercise of public law," said the ministry.
Discover more
Watch
End of Watch




