Face of the unpopular war in Iran, the controversial Pete Hegseth appears to be an ideal scapegoat after the debacle of the Trump camp in the mid-term elections. While Democrats say they want to dismiss this loyalist among the president's loyalists, some Republican elected officials plan to put his indictment to a vote next week.

Published on: 05/11/2026 - 16:33

After the rout in the midterms of November 3, he seems to be a perfect fuse in the Republican camp: criticized for months for his management of the war in Iran and the lack of transparency of the Pentagon, Pete Hegseth finds himself in the sights of Congress and could face, in the coming days, a dismissal procedure from elected Republican officials.

Kentucky MP Thomas Massie, a former supporter of Donald Trump, of whom he has become a fierce opponent, confirmed his intention to trigger an impeachment vote against the Secretary of State for Defense as soon as Congress resumes work next week, unless the latter resigns.

According to Republican sources, this vote has every chance of being adopted thanks to the votes of Republican elected officials who were defeated in the elections and who therefore have nothing left to lose. As for the Democrats, they have made the Minister of Defense a priority target of the new legislature.

Also read Corruption, Epstein file... the Democrats are preparing a series of investigations into the Trump clan

“I'm here to tell you that one of the first steps we'll take when we have a majority is to run Pete Hegseth out of town,” House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries said recently.

If no strategy has yet been decided by the Democratic leadership, some elected officials believe it is preferable to attack Donald Trump's supporters rather than launch a third "impeachment" procedure against the American president, already acquitted twice by the Senate during his first term.

“Not everyone agrees on how to proceed but I think that there will not be a sufficiently large majority within the Democratic Party to file an “impeachment” procedure against a president who is 80 years old and who only has two years of mandate left before him,” deciphers Jérôme Viala-Gaudefroy, doctor in American civilization and teacher at Sciences-Po.

“Abuse of power”

Similar to that targeting the American president, the procedure for “impeachment” of a minister begins with an indictment of the House of Representatives, which votes by a simple majority. The indictment is then transmitted to the Senate which pronounces dismissal if a two-thirds majority of the members present is reached. That's 67 out of 100 U.S. senators. Democrats have a 54-seat majority at this point.

But what do American elected officials have against Pete Hegseth? Deputy Thomas Massie already filed a resolution in September containing eight counts of indictment for “serious crimes and minor offenses” before the Judiciary Committee of the House of Representatives.

The elected Republican accuses Pete Hegseth in particular of having led the conflict in Iran without a declaration of war by Congress and of having exceeded the 60-day limit beyond which parliamentarians must give their consent to the continuation of hostilities.

“The constitutional violations committed by Secretary Hegseth are not limited to the illegal war in Iran,” assures Thomas Massie to USA Today. "He abuses his power to ignore Congressional resolutions on war powers, to kidnap foreign leaders and to intimidate critics of the Trump administration [...]", believes the MP, referring in particular to the capture of Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro.

He also believes that the Minister of Defense broke the law intended to limit civilian casualties, notably in Yemen and Iran, carried out illegal strikes in the Caribbean against drug traffickers' boats and carried out extrajudicial executions.

A divisive figure

Beyond this list of charges, Pete Hegseth is strongly criticized on the left for his unbridled virilist discourse, his purges carried out in the ranks of the army and his policy of discrimination against African-Americans and women in military promotions. He was also singled out for compromising classified information on Signal messaging. Finally, the war in Iran, launched without a strategy or way out, confirmed, according to many elected officials, the incompetence trial that sticks with it.

It must be said that since his appointment, Pete Hegseth has not made many friends on Capitol Hill. Narrowly confirmed to his post by the Senate in January 2025, the profile of this former soldier gives a cold sweat to elected officials from both camps: notorious alcoholism, lack of experience, accusation of sexual assault, ultranationalist ideology... the CV of the former Fox News presenter has always seemed out of step with his job description: leading the world's first army and a ministry with a budget of 850 billion dollars a year, employing some three million soldiers, reservists and civilians.

"He created a climate of fear at the Pentagon accompanied by a total lack of transparency since he limited media access to the headquarters of the Ministry of Defense. He also pays for the failure of everything he undertakes, in particular the war in Iran. He clearly appears today as the weak link in a country which maintains a very positive relationship with its army", affirms Jérôme Viala-Gaudefroy, citing the example of the emotion aroused by the testimonies describing the living conditions American sailors aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln.

Still supported by Trump

However, despite the rout of the midterms and the growing pressure from his own camp, Donald Trump does not yet seem decided to let go of one of his most loyal lieutenants. Asked on Wednesday about the future of his defense minister, the president denied wanting to dismiss him, saying he was "doing a very good job."

To try to protect his Minister of War, according to the term used by the Trump administration, Admiral Brad Cooper, head of American Central Command, or General Dan Caine, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, would be pushed towards the exit, reports CBS News, citing White House advisers.

According to CNN, keeping Pete Hegseth in office also offers an advantage to Donald Trump: maintaining room for maneuver in his conduct of the war in Iran, particularly if Wasington decides on new strike campaigns. Especially since the new Democratic majority in the Senate will have a say in the appointment of new members of the government.

Read alsoMidterms: what a Democratic majority in Congress changes for Trump and the Republicans

"For Trump, it's also a way of not letting things be dictated to him. But he is also capable of pushing him under the bus if that becomes necessary. In this context, it will be interesting to see the number of Republicans who will vote in favor of the impeachment of Pete Hegseth", affirms Jérôme Viala-Gaudefroy.

If impeached by the House of Representatives, Pete Hegseth would become the third member of an American government to be the subject of a similar procedure.

In 1876, Secretary of War William Belknap was impeached for corruption and later acquitted by the Senate. Closer to us, in 2024, Joe Biden's Secretary of Homeland Security, Alejandro Mayorkas, was targeted by an attempted "impeachment" because of his migration policy on the border with Mexico. The Senate, then with a Democratic majority, buried the procedure without going to the final stage of voting.

Keywords associated with the article

The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.