Image source: Indranil Aditya/NurPhoto via Getty Images

There is a stir in the politics of Uttar Pradesh due to two comments which have gone viral on social media in the last few days.

Samajwadi Party seems aggressive on both these issues, while Bharatiya Janata Party seems a little uneasy.

The first comment is from Hindu religious leader Dhirendra Shastri, known by his followers as Bageshwar Baba. The second comment is from Sangeet Ragi, a professor of political science at Delhi University and associated with the RSS.

Dhirendra Shastri had made controversial remarks comparing Lord Ram and Krishna. At the same time, Sangeet Ragi had used objectionable and caste based words for Samajwadi Party spokesperson Manoj Yadav Kaka during a live debate on a TV channel.

However, Sangeet Ragi later clarified and apologized and said that his comment was not for any particular community. At the same time, Dhirendra Shastri has also apologized for his remarks.

But Samajwadi Party is continuously attacking both of them.

Dhirendra Shastri's Katha program is proposed from 17th November in Kunda, UP. Akhilesh Yadav is demanding cancellation of these programs.

Earlier, Samajwadi Party workers had filed a complaint at Hazratganj police station in Lucknow on Wednesday to register an FIR against Dhirendra Shastri.

End

At the same time, SP spokesperson Manoj Yadav demonstrated in support of 'Kaka' and tried to burn the effigy of Sangeet Ragi.

Many leaders of opposition parties have also reacted to these statements. These include Samajwadi Party President Akhilesh Yadav, Aam Aadmi Party leader Sanjay Singh, RJD leader Tejashwi Yadav and Purnia MP Pappu Yadav.

Image Sourced

Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava

Learn more

There is also a political challenge in front of BJP regarding these two statements and the proposed programs of Shastri. Especially because assembly elections are to be held in Uttar Pradesh and Samajwadi Party may try to make these issues a part of the election debate.

A senior leader of the Samajwadi Party, on the condition of anonymity, told BBC that both the comments are absolutely wrong. He said that the party will continue to raise these issues even during the elections.

At the same time, BJP spokesperson Rakesh Tripathi says that there is a need to avoid such statements. According to him, "This does not suit them at all. But did the Samajwadi Party leaders not comment on Brahmins, Kshatriyas and Vaishyas? Did they not insult them? Regional people are insulted every day. Samajwadi Party is trying to divide Hindus. But we are confident that Hindus will not divide and will remain with BJP."

But can these two comments have any impact on the electoral politics of Uttar Pradesh? Will Samajwadi Party be able to turn this into a big political issue against BJP? Or will the electoral impact of these statements not be as much as is currently visible?

Image Source: Facebook/Akhilesh Yadav

Senior journalist Sunita Aron believes that Dhirendra Shastri's comments should not be seen only from the perspective of political gain or loss to the Samajwadi Party.

She says, "Is Dhirendra Shastri also trying to divide God on the basis of caste? This question is not about the political benefit of the Samajwadi Party, but it hurts the devotees of Krishna. The devotees of Krishna are not only Yaduvanshi. A large number of people also come to Mathura from Gujarat and Delhi."

According to Sunita Aron, "BJP will obviously be uncomfortable with this comment, because some of the party leaders have been promoting Dhirendra Shastri or have been associated with him. BJP and RSS should openly condemn such statements. Their silence can make the matter worse. Samajwadi Party can get political benefit from it."

Image source: Getty Images

Senior journalist Vinod Sharma also agrees with this. He says that BJP has been trying to break into the traditional Yadav vote bank of Samajwadi Party in Uttar Pradesh for a long time.

For this, along with promoting the leaders of the Yadav community, the party has also given place to the religious identity associated with Lord Krishna in its politics. An attempt has also been made to reach out to the wider Hindu voters through the issue of Krishna Janmabhoomi in Mathura.

In such a situation, Dhirendra Shastri's comment about Lord Krishna can also pose a challenge to this strategy of BJP.

However, Dhirendra Shastri has apologized in this matter and said that his words were misinterpreted. But Vinod Sharma believes that it will not make any difference. According to him, the damage that was to be done has already been done.

At the same time, RJD and Samajwadi Party are also aggressive regarding Sangeet Ragi's comments.

Vinod Sharma says, "Yadav has not been a core voter of BJP. This is true, but BJP has been trying to make a dent in that vote bank for a long time. Making Mohan Yadav the Chief Minister of Madhya Pradesh, Mohan Yadav's arrival at the Yadav Mahakumbh held in Lucknow in March 2024 and appealing to people to be proud of their Yaduvanshi identity, creating a divide between Mulayam Singh Yadav and his brothers, all these are examples of efforts being made in the same direction."

Image source: Raju Shinde/Hindustan Times via Getty Images

BJP's efforts to reach out to the Yadav community in Uttar Pradesh are not new.

After coming to power in UP in 2017, the then Deputy Chief Minister Keshav Prasad Maurya had said that till now the party was focusing on non-Yadav OBCs, but now it will focus on Yadavs also.

After this, the party experimented with honoring influential people of the Yadav community, visiting Yadav workers' homes and having meals and giving place to community leaders in the organization.

Inclusion of Mulayam Singh Yadav's daughter-in-law Aparna Yadav in the party before the 2022 assembly elections and later promoting Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Mohan Yadav in Uttar Pradesh has also been a part of this broader political effort.

In an India Today report in 2022 itself, a BJP official was quoted as saying that the party is paying special attention to the youth of the Yadav community, who are not much influenced by the political influence of Akhilesh Yadav.

The party's effort was to connect such youth with organizational and electoral activities at the local level.

In the same report, a BJP leader had claimed that the party had received Yadav votes even in Yadav dominated areas like Badaun, Azamgarh, Etawah and Kannauj.

However, it would be wrong to say that BJP is completely on the back foot after these statements. A person who understands BJP's politics said on the condition of anonymity that the more the debate between Lord Ram and Krishna increases, the more BJP will benefit.

This is also mentioned in an article published on the same issue in the Indian Express. According to the article, BJP is counter-attacking Samajwadi Party and RJD on this issue.

Taking aim at Akhilesh Yadav and Tejashwi Yadav, BJP spokesperson Naveen Srivastava said, "Now that elections are approaching, Akhilesh Yadav and Tejashwi Yadav have suddenly started remembering Lord Krishna. But Akhilesh Yadav, who has not gone to Ram temple and has raised questions on the existence of Lord Ram, will tell when will he go to Krishna Janmabhoomi in Mathura? Do he support the Krishna Janmabhoomi temple movement or not?"

That is, BJP is trying to turn this entire controversy into a question for the Samajwadi Party to clarify its stand on Ram Temple and Krishna Janmabhoomi.

But senior journalist Neerja Chaudhary questions this strategy of BJP.

She says that right now the issue of Krishna Janmabhoomi is not at the center of the election debate. Even if this is made an issue, questions will arise before BJP. On one hand there is talk of building a temple and on the other hand such comments are being made about Lord Krishna. In such a situation, the question will arise as to why BJP is not openly criticizing these comments.

She also expresses apprehension that the statements of Dhirendra Shastri and Sangeet Ragi do not appear to have been made by mistake, rather it seems that they have been given intentionally.

Neerja Chaudhary also raises the question whether there are some people in Uttar Pradesh who do not want Yogi Adityanath to remain in power.

He believes that these statements can further unite the Yadav vote bank. He says that such Yadav leaders and candidates present in Congress, who did not want to join Samajwadi Party, may also hesitate to join BJP.

Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.

Download the new BBC World Service app

Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place

Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.

short video

end of short video

top story

Controversial comments on Krishna and Yadav community, will it affect UP elections?

Live, Why was a fatwa issued against Nike in Libya?

How are Ranbir Kapoor-Sai Pallavi's 'Ramayana' being received by critics in India and abroad?

must read

most popular