Moroccan researcher and journalist Hassan Bentaleb chose to open a chapter of the wounds of migration from Morocco to France through the book “The Coal of All Tragedies,” which takes the reader back to the era of the 1950s and 1960s. This period witnessed a large wave of migration from the countryside of the Kingdom to northern France to work in mines in extremely harsh conditions. The publication of this book “is not to cry over the past, but to avoid reproducing it,” according to what Bentaleb said in an interview with France 24.
Published on: 04/14/2026 - 14:23 Last updated: 04/14/2026 - 19:49
The migration of Moroccans to France to work in mines was considered one of the most important waves of labor migration between the two countries during the twentieth century, especially in the period extending from the 1950s to the 1970s. The immigrants came to meet France's urgent need for labor after World War II, as the country sought to rebuild its economy and industries.
These workers worked in very difficult conditions, spending long hours underground in an environment full of dangers, such as collapses and respiratory diseases. They also lived in simple communal housing, and often suffered from social marginalization and weak rights compared to French workers.
Despite these harsh conditions, Moroccan workers played an important role in supporting the French economy during the reconstruction phase. Over time, many of them settled in France and brought their families, which contributed to forming the nucleus of the Moroccan community, which today has become one of the largest communities in France.
Moroccan journalist and researcher in immigration affairs, Hassan Bentaleb, dedicated a book to this category entitled: “The Coal of All Tragedies... The Forgotten History of Moroccan Miners in Pas de Calais” in northern France. An article about this book in the Socialist Union newspaper stated that it is “a documentary and investigative work that revives one of the most painful and marginalized pages in the history of Moroccan immigration.”
Through this work, Bentaleb delves into the harsh conditions surrounding the deportation of these workers from their remote villages in Morocco to the depths of French mines, where they faced exploitation, discrimination, and isolation far from their families and their country.
Bentaleb recalls the role of "Felix Mora", who was known as "the slaver of modern times", in leading the humiliating selection processes for these men, who were often illiterate and poor, deprived of their most basic rights, and treated as a raw, replaceable labor force.
France 24 interviewed Hassan Bentaleb and conducted the following interview:
What led you to research the issue of Moroccan miners in northern France? Is it the current immigration reality or other reasons?
Motivation cannot be reduced to the “now” alone, but rather is the product of tension between three temporal levels: the past (the miners’ experience), the present (contemporary migration transformations), and the future (public policy questions).
What I noticed is that the public debate about immigration in Morocco - whether media or political - suffers from a lack of memory. Migration is treated as a temporary phenomenon, when in fact it is an extended historical structure. This is where the idea came from: returning to the miners’ experience is not only a documentary work, but an attempt to understand how systems of exploitation are formed over time, and how they reproduce themselves in different forms. In other words: I did not search the past because it ended, but because it did not actually end.
What are the most prominent events and ideas that must be urgently considered when raising the issue of Moroccan miners?
There are three levels at which one must dwell deeply:
1. Exploitation as a system, not as a situation
The book shows that what the miners were subjected to was not an aberration, but rather part of a global economic system based on an unequal division of labor. The migrant here is not just a worker, but a functional body to be consumed.
2. Manufactured fragility
Fragility was not “natural,” but was produced through:
Unequal employment contracts
Lack of social protection
Social and cultural isolation
Meaning that the system needs the vulnerability of the immigrant in order to survive.
3. Absence of historical justice
Not only because compensation is insufficient, but also because: memory has not been integrated into policies and experience has not been transformed into institutional knowledge. This is more dangerous, because it allows the same mistakes to be reproduced.
Did the 2011 ruling in the French city of Douai in favor of these workers achieve what is known as reparation?
The ruling must be read on two levels:
Legal level: It is an important recognition of a historical responsibility, and this in itself is an achievement.
Sociological level: It does not amount to reparation, because the damage here is not reducible to money:
· Chronic diseases
· Social disintegration
· Loss of meaning and dignity
It can be said that the referee addressed the result, but did not touch the structure that produced the damage.
Why mix academic research and journalistic investigation in “The Coal of All Tragedies”?
This choice was not technical, but epistemological. There is a real problem with studying migration: academic research tends to be abstract and journalism tends to be reductionist or sensationalist. What I tried to do was overcome this division by building a hybrid approach based on:
Structural analysis
· Reconstructing the human experience (lived experience)
Because the truth is that: exploitation is not only understood in numbers, nor is it perceived only with testimonies, but in the area where the system meets the individual experience.
This combination allowed for the revelation of what might be called: “silent violence” — that is, the kind of violence that does not appear in official discourses, but is strongly present in the details of migrants’ daily lives.
Why is this situation repeated today? Where is the error?
The idea that “history repeats itself” is inaccurate. More precisely: structures reproduce themselves in new forms
Today we see the same logic in:
· Strawberry workers
· Agricultural workers
· Irregular workers
But with different tools.
The defect lies on three levels:
1. Economically: Morocco’s continued position in an unequal global value chain that exports labor and imports fragility
2. Politically: Weak international negotiations to protect workers and the absence of proactive policies
3. Socially: Immigration turns into an individual project for salvation instead of a collective issue. This is the most dangerous transformation, because it transfers responsibility from the system to the individual.
Will you continue this experience in researching and documenting migration with other works?
This work opened a more complex research path than I expected. The question today is no longer just: "What happened?" Rather, it became: How is migration produced as a system? How is its discourse produced in the media and politics?
The next stage - if it continues - will be towards:
· Analysis of the discourse on migration (as in Migrapress)/ (Moroccan research center on migration)
· Linking memory to public policies
· Study of new transformations (South-South migration, digital migration...)
This book is not just about miners. Rather, it is about something deeper: how a person turns into a tool within an economic system, how this is justified politically, and how this is collectively forgotten.
In the end: it is an attempt to answer a difficult question: How can we benefit from memory, not to cry over the past, but to avoid reproducing it?
Keywords related to the article
The content you want to browse is no longer in service or is currently unavailable.




