Image source: AFP via Getty Images
The Lebanese newspaper "An-Nahar" launched a campaign demanding the abolition of Article 534 of the Penal Code in Lebanon, which is used to criminalize consensual same-sex relations between adults.
This article, which stipulates the punishment of “any unnatural sexual intercourse,” dates back to the Penal Code issued in 1943, and is still the subject of legal and legal controversy, in light of repeated calls for its abolition.
These demands collide with opposition within the Lebanese Parliament, for reasons related to religious beliefs and social positions, as well as electoral calculations that make some representatives avoid delving into the issue for fear of losing the support of a portion of their voters.
The main religious authorities in Lebanon, regardless of their sects, agree in rejecting same-sex relations, a position that is also reflected in the political debate regarding individual rights and freedoms.
Al-Nahar is not the first Lebanese media outlet to open the issue of LGBT rights, as Al-Akhbar newspaper and a number of television programs have previously devoted coverage to these issues.
The debate often dominates the human rights and legal debate, especially in television programs that bring together clerics and figures who refuse to decriminalize same-sex relations, confronting people from the LGBT community and defenders of their rights.
This controversy usually returns to the forefront following incidents that provoke mixed reactions, such as the attack by a group known as the “Soldiers of God” on a nightclub that was hosting an art show, or following the announcement of gatherings and marches in support of the rights of the LGBT community, which sometimes face objections and calls to ban them.
In its latest campaign, Al-Nahar devoted the cover of its November 16 issue to this issue, under the title “Article 534 is not natural,” in reversing the phrase on which the legal text is based to criminalize sexual practices, which it describes as “unnatural.”
Most read end
Stay updated with the latest current affairs
Download the app
BBC Arabic application for mobile phones
The cover was designed in the colors of the rainbow flag, but the newspaper used these colors to indicate Lebanese political parties, so that each color represents a party according to the color of its flag. These parties, most of which represent different Lebanese sects, collectively hold the majority of seats in Parliament.
The Al-Nahar editorial board explained that it chose the International Day for Tolerance, which falls on November 16, to open this file, more than eight decades after the adoption of Article 534.
She pointed to the continued implementation of the article despite the issuance of judicial jurisprudence that considered that consensual same-sex relations between adults do not fall within the acts punishable by this text, in addition to submitting a law proposal to abolish it in 2023.
The newspaper asked a question about the price that people concerned with this substance pay in their daily lives, in light of the continued validity of a legal text whose wording allows them to be prosecuted for their consensual sexual relations.
The "An-Nahar" campaign sparked criticism from various quarters, as some commentators objected to the involvement of traditional parties in discussing the rights of the LGBT community, considering that they bear part of the responsibility for the continuation of discriminatory laws and the absence of legal protection.
On the other hand, commentators refused to demand the decriminalization of same-sex relationships, and comments on social media sites included insults and inflammatory statements.
Image source: ANNAHAR
What is Article 534?
Article 534 of the Lebanese Penal Code stipulates that “any sexual intercourse contrary to nature” shall be punished with imprisonment for a period not exceeding one year.
Human rights organizations and activists defending the rights of the LGBT community have been calling for the abolition of this article for years.
The activity of organizations defending the rights of the LGBT community in Lebanon dates back more than two decades, the most prominent of which is the “Helem” Association, which was founded at the beginning of the millennium, and works to defend these rights and provide legal and social support to people exposed to discrimination and persecution.
But this activity faces challenges in a society where attitudes rejecting same-sex relationships are still strongly present, especially in religious and conservative circles.
Human rights organizations documented incitement and hate speech campaigns targeting members of the LGBT community, including threats, physical attacks, and attempts to prevent activities and gatherings in support of their rights, in addition to some of them being subjected to family ostracism, discrimination, and blackmail.
Al-Nahar newspaper published a copy of a law proposal submitted in 2023 to abolish Article 534, and it was signed by a number of male and female representatives from traditional political parties and independents.
The proposal is not limited to canceling the article, but also stipulates dropping the lawsuits and prosecutions related to it, and not referring any of the cases or files covered by its provisions to judicial authorities.
What is the position of the Lebanese parties on amending the law?
Al-Nahar newspaper indicated that the Lebanese parties that contacted it hesitated to answer their questions regarding the abolition of Article 534, and some of them tried to evade taking a clear position by referring the newspaper to their representatives in Parliament, while other officials preferred not to reveal their names.
The newspaper asked the parties two questions: Do you support amending Article 534 of the Penal Code? Are its representatives obligated to vote in favor of the amendment in the House of Representatives?
The survey included the Lebanese Phalange parties, the Lebanese Forces, and the Free Patriotic Movement, which are among the most prominent political forces with a Christian popular base, along with the Future Movement, which has a Sunni popular base, the Amal Movement and Hezbollah, which represent the two most prominent political forces in Shiite circles, and the Progressive Socialist Party, which enjoys broad influence in Druze circles.
The newspaper also reviewed the position of the “Male and Female Citizens in a State” movement, and in other coverage it addressed the opinions of male and female representatives from outside the traditional parties regarding the proposal to abolish the article.
The positions of the three Christian-based parties intersected when they supported the decriminalization of same-sex relations, although they differed in justifying this position and the limits of the rights they support recognizing.
In the Free Patriotic Movement, lawyer Jumana Salilati, coordinator of the Communication and Public Relations Committee, said that the party supports decriminalization in line with human rights principles and international agreements, noting that the phrase “against nature” bears different interpretations according to religious beliefs and social and cultural views.
She stressed that decriminalization does not necessarily mean encouraging same-sex relationships, stressing at the same time the need to preserve social values, as she put it.
As for the Lebanese Forces Party, the head of the Media and Communications Authority, Jad Damian, referred the newspaper’s questions to MP George Okais, who confirmed that the party’s position is based on its political, social and religious authority, saying: “We follow the church and we cannot be either to its right or to its left.”
Akis explained that representatives from the “Strong Republic” bloc signed the proposal to abolish Article 534, with the aim of lifting the criminal penalty for same-sex relations, and not declaring the party’s support for these relations or adopting other demands related to the rights of gays and lesbians.
He pointed out that the legal text belongs to a past period, and that demanding its abolition does not necessarily mean changing the party’s position on the social and religious aspects of the issue.
In the same context, Representative Razi Al-Hajj previously explained in 2023 that the Lebanese Forces distinguish between refusing to criminalize same-sex relations and passing legislation that recognizes them.
In the Lebanese Phalange Party, the head of the Foreign Relations Authority, Marwan Abdullah, confirmed the party’s support for decriminalizing same-sex relations, considering it a personal matter that should not expose individuals to judicial prosecution.
Abdullah pointed out that this position is not new, but was stated in the party’s electoral programs for 2018 and 2022.
But he distinguished between abolishing the criminal penalty and recognizing other rights, such as same-sex marriage and adopting children, explaining that supporting decriminalization does not necessarily mean the party agrees with all demands related to the rights of the LGBT community.
On the other hand, a source in the Future Movement, whose leader Saad Hariri suspended his participation in political life in 2022, merely told the newspaper, “No comment.”
The source justified not taking a position by saying that deciding on law proposals rests with the House of Representatives, as the movement does not enjoy parliamentary representation after its participation in the elections was suspended, adding that there are other more urgent files on which no official position has been issued by the movement.
As for the Amal Movement, the newspaper quoted its central cultural official, Judge Sheikh Hassan Abdullah, as rejecting same-sex relations, based on religious and social considerations.
Abdullah believed that these relationships conflict with the religious concept of the family, but he referred the issue of decriminalization to the religious and spiritual authorities, considering it to be within their jurisdiction.
The newspaper recalled that the former Minister of Culture, Muhammad al-Murtada, affiliated with the Amal Movement, had proposed in 2023 a draft law aimed at imposing penalties on the promotion of same-sex relations or sex change, in the midst of controversy over the proposal to abolish Article 534.
From Hezbollah, MP Ihab Hamadeh, a member of the “Loyalty to the Resistance” bloc, relied on religious texts to justify his rejection of same-sex relations, considering that they conflict with human nature and threaten the continuity of the family and society.
The newspaper recalled previous positions of the party, including statements by its former Secretary General Hassan Nasrallah in 2023, in which he called for confronting homosexuality, and official positions issued by its parliamentary bloc that rejected demands related to the rights of the LGBT community.
As for the Progressive Socialist Party, it did not present a clear position on the abolition of Article 534.
An-Nahar quoted a source in the party as saying that it seeks to reconcile respect for human rights, personal freedoms, and international agreements on the one hand, and taking into account social and religious values and public morals on the other hand, without clarifying its position on abolishing the criminal penalty or how its representatives would vote if the proposal was put forward in Parliament.
On the other hand, the “Citizens in a State” movement, which adopts a secular approach, expressed a position in support of individual freedoms and rejected state interference in consensual sexual relations between adults.
Movement member Ahmed Al-Assi stressed that individuals are free with their bodies as long as they do not assault others, linking this position to the rejection of political and religious guardianship over personal choices.
Find out more
Short clips
End of short clips




