Image source: Getty Images

Under Indian criminal law, forcing a woman to have sex against her will is rape. But if a woman aged 18 years or older is married to a man who has sex with her against her will, then it is not considered rape.

Now the Supreme Court will decide on the legal validity of this exception. Hearing on 10 petitions related to this case will start from Wednesday.

During the hearing held in September 2026, Justice Joymalya Bagchi had said that if a woman is forced by her husband to have sex, then she is 'definitely a victim'.

Justice Bagchi, who was included in the bench hearing the case along with Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justice V. Mohana, had said that the question is 'whether the state considers it rape or not.'

He had said, "This is the existing law, whether right or wrong. It is a punitive law."

He had raised the question whether the courts could allow rape cases before deciding on the constitutional validity of this exemption.

The Supreme Court's decision will decide whether married women will get the same legal protection against sexual violence as unmarried women.

The data of National Family Health Survey-5 (2019-21) shows the seriousness of this problem.

End

Among married women aged 18 to 49 who had ever experienced sexual violence, 82 percent blamed their current husband and 14 percent blamed their former husband.

Overall, 4.6 percent of married women in this age group reported that their husbands used physical force to have sex without their consent.

At the same time, 3.8 percent women said that their husbands forced them to perform such sexual acts which they did not want, through threats or other means.

Marital rape is clearly considered a crime in most countries of the world. India is among those around 50 countries where it is not considered a crime.

What is the legal question?

In this case, Exception-2 of Section 375 of the colonial-era Indian Penal Code (IPC) has been legally challenged. This exception-2 has also been retained in Section 63 of the Indian Judicial Code (BNS) of 2023.

Under this, sexual relations or sexual acts done by a husband with a wife who is 18 years of age or older is not considered rape.

The Supreme Court bench has to decide whether this exception deprives married women of their fundamental rights like equality under Article 14 of the Constitution, protection from discrimination under Article 15 and right to life, dignity, privacy and right over their own body under Article 21.

The question before the court will also be whether eliminating this exception will create a new offence. Parliament has the right to do this.

What is the demand made in the petitions?

Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava

Learn more

One of these petitions has been filed by a husband. He is challenging the Karnataka High Court's 2022 decision, which allowed the rape case initiated by his wife to continue.

The four appeals are related to the divided decision of the Delhi High Court in 2022.

All India Democratic Women's Association (ADWA) and a woman are demanding quashing of the opinion in which this exception was upheld. This woman has accused her husband of forcing her to have sex.

At the same time, Main Welfare Trust and Hridaya Nest of Family Harmony are challenging the second opinion, in which it was said that this exception should be abolished.

The four petitions filed directly in the Supreme Court include those by Youth for Equality in 2019, social activist Ruth Manorama in 2022, AIDWA in 2024 and Aveksha Women's Charitable Trust in 2025.

In all these there has been a demand to declare this exception unconstitutional.

Some petitioners have also challenged Section 376B of the IPC. Under this section, if a estranged husband forcibly has sex with his wife, he can be jailed for two to seven years. This is less than the minimum punishment of 10 years prescribed for rape.

Apart from this, the petitioners have also challenged Section 198B of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Under this section, some additional procedural conditions have to be fulfilled before hearing such cases in the courts.

Red Dot Foundation filed a petition in May 2026. In this, the decisions of Karnataka and Delhi High Courts of 2022, an order of Delhi High Court of 2025 and the decisions of Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat, Uttarakhand and Chhattisgarh High Courts have been challenged.

Those supporting this exception argue that existing laws have adequate provisions to deal with marital violence and only Parliament has the power to change the definition of rape.

What have been the decisions of the High Court?

Over the past several years, different High Courts have given different decisions on the question of consent within marriage.

In 1983, the Andhra Pradesh High Court had struck down Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act. This is a civil law, under which courts can order separated husband and wife to live together again. This is called 'restoration of conjugal rights'.

The High Court had said that this could force women to have sexual relations with a husband from whom they have been separated.

Therefore, the state sending her back to her husband is a violation of the wife's right to privacy, dignity and equality under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution.

In 2018, Gujarat High Court judge Justice JB Pardiwala had dismissed the rape charge against a doctor. The doctor's wife had accused him of forcing her to have sex. Justice Pardiwala is now a judge of the Supreme Court.

He had said that Exception 2 of Section 375 'gives protection to the husband in this situation'.

That is, the alleged acts could have been considered rape under Section 375, but due to the existence of a valid marriage, a case could not be filed against the husband, even if the sexual relations had taken place without his consent.

The court had also dropped the charges under section 377 of the IPC. This section criminalized 'unnatural sexual acts' and was generally used in cases of oral or anal sex.

However, the court had upheld the charges against the husband under IPC section 498A for cruelty and section 354 for outraging the dignity of a woman.

In his decision, Justice Pardiwala had appealed to the Parliament to eliminate this exception. He reminded husbands that "marriage is not a license to forcibly rape your wife." He called it a "violent act and injustice" that should be criminalized.

In March 2022, Justice M Nagaprasanna of the Karnataka High Court had refused to dismiss a rape charge against a man.

The man was accused of raping his wife. The court had also ordered to add section 377 of IPC in the case.

Describing the law that makes exception to marital rape as 'backward', the court had said, "A man is a man, an act is an act and rape is rape. Even if this act is done by a man i.e. 'husband' with a woman i.e. 'wife'."

The court appealed to Parliament to "listen to the voices of the silenced" and end this exception. The Supreme Court had stayed this order in July 2022.

Two months later, two judges of the Delhi High Court gave different decisions on this question.

Justice Rajiv Shakdhar had rejected this exception, Section 376B of the IPC and Section 198B of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

He had termed the principle of considering consent as permanent after marriage as wrong. On the basis of this principle, marital rape gets immunity.

Citing the National Family Health Survey of 2015-16, she said that 99.1 percent of cases of sexual violence go unreported and women are 17 times more likely to face sexual violence from their husbands than others.

He had said that not naming rape deprives wives of facilities like anonymity, medical aid and compensation.

He also said that excluding husbands from this legal exemption does not mean creating a new crime.

At the same time, Justice C Hari Shankar had upheld these three provisions.

He believed that a husband cannot force his wife to have sex. But he described marriage as a unique relationship in which there is a "legitimate expectation of sexual relations".

According to him, the 'limit of anger' of a wife is different compared to being raped by a stranger.

He warned that the court's elimination of this exception would create a new crime. Due to this, a minimum punishment of 10 years can be imposed.

Besides this, Section 114A of the Evidence Act will also apply. Under this, sexual relations are proved and the woman says that she had not given consent.

Justice Hari Shankar had said that this could make it "extremely difficult, nay, almost impossible" for a husband to prove that his wife had given consent "within the confines of the bedroom".

In three High Court decisions between 2024 and 2025, prosecutions under Section 377 of the IPC were barred against the husbands.

The Red Dot Foundation has challenged these decisions. Some women used Section 377 against their husbands because rape charges were not available.

After the amendments in 2013, oral and anal sex were also included in the definition of rape in the IPC. Also, the scope of Exception 2 was expanded to include “sexual intercourse or sexual act of a man with his wife”.

After this, Uttarakhand High Court in 2024 and Chhattisgarh and Delhi High Court in 2025 did not give permission to file charges against the husbands under Section 377.

The courts said that under Exception 2, the question of consent between the husband and wife is not important.

The Chhattisgarh High Court had acquitted a man who was convicted for allegedly causing fatal injuries to his wife. The court had said that the wife's "non-consent loses its significance."

What is the stance of the governments?

In the affidavit filed before the Supreme Court in the present case in October 2024, the Central Government had opposed the abolition of this exception.

The Union Home Ministry had said that "marriage does not take away a woman's consent" and that marital sex without consent should be punished.

But the ministry said that calling it 'rape' under sections 375 and 376 of the IPC, which carry a minimum punishment of 10 years and strict evidentiary rules, "may be considered too harsh and therefore disproportionate."

The ministry had said there were 'adequate measures' in place under Section 498A for cruelty by husband, Section 354 for insulting the modesty of a woman, Section 354A for sexual harassment, Section 354B for forcing her to disrobe and the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005.

Instead of making the matter a crime, the government described it as a 'social question on which Parliament has decided its stand.'

After the gang rape in Delhi in 2012, in 2013, a committee headed by Justice JS Verma had recommended reforms in criminal laws.

The committee had recommended eliminating this exception and not considering marriage as a ground for immunity or reduction in punishment.

But Parliament did not eliminate this exception while changing the definition of rape in the IPC in 2013 and while creating the BNS in 2023.

Parliament had cited the 172nd Law Commission report of 2000. The report warned that doing so could lead to "undue interference in the marital relationship."

Additionally, a 2013 parliamentary committee also said that removing this exception could 'destroy the institution of marriage' and put 'enormous strain' on families.

Of the 19 state and union territory governments that responded after consultation with the states, 10 supported maintaining this exception. These included Assam, Chhattisgarh, Goa, Uttar Pradesh, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, Manipur, Uttarakhand, Chandigarh and Ladakh.

Delhi, Tripura and Karnataka had opposed it. The remaining six governments did not give any opinion on this.

The National Commission for Women had said, "Due to the absence of a strong support system for the victims, wives and children may have to face the situation of destitution and wandering." The Commission had supported maintaining the existing system.

The Union Ministry of Women and Child Development had also adopted the same stance. The ministry had expressed apprehension that changing this law "could have a serious impact on marital relations and could create a serious crisis in the institution of marriage."

The ministry had also said that this law could be misused because 'it would be difficult and challenging for a person to prove whether there was consent or not.'

Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.

Download the new BBC World Service app

Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place

Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.

short video

end of short video

top story

Supreme Court will decide whether marital rape is a crime or not

Many world leaders including Trump-Putin reached China's 'AI Wonderland', know why this city is special

Live, alert of drone attacks in Kuwait, army activated air defense system

must read

most popular