Image source: AFP via Getty Images

“I was so happy when I moved here, and I was finally able to relax,” says Abdel Wahab Damdoum, as he looks at his luxurious new apartment overlooking the Mediterranean Sea in the city of Derna, located in eastern Libya.

Just three years ago, Dumdum was terrified clinging to the roof of a house as the waters of the world's deadliest flood this century swept around him.

Today, the 27-year-old port worker, his wife and two young daughters received a free new home with an area of ​​300 square meters as part of an exhibition urban project commissioned by one of the sons of Khalifa Haftar, the military commander who controls eastern Libya.

The project is part of a rapid reconstruction of the city of Derna at a cost of two billion dollars, which the influential Haftar family hopes will be a model for development throughout Libya, thus strengthening its influence in a country that is still divided between east and west, each of which runs a government competing with the other for power.

The funding comes from the state treasury in this oil-rich country after Parliament issued a decision regarding financial allocations for the project. However, there are no published records showing how this money was spent, raising questions about accountability and possible corrupt practices.

Damdoum, like many flood survivors, can only thank the head of the Libya Development and Reconstruction Fund, Belkacem Haftar, for what has been achieved since the early hours of September 11, 2023, when heavy rains resulting from Hurricane Daniel caused the collapse of two dams located above Derna, sending huge waves seven meters high rushing towards the city that was asleep.

The true number of victims may never be known. Some estimates indicated that the number of deaths had reached 6,000 people, but the number closest to reality currently appears to be approximately 4,000 people. There are still a large number of bodies whose owners cannot be identified.

In a city with a population of nearly 100,000 - meaning almost everyone lost a loved one - all 14 relatives and neighbors who were on the roof with Dumdum drowned, including his father, brother and sister.

Most read end

Image source: Tim Whewell/BBC

Stay updated with the latest current affairs

Download the app

BBC Arabic application for mobile phones

Dumdum survived, but his house was completely destroyed, and he had to look for temporary housing.

The survivor of the deadly floods says: "I used to pay the rent over and over again. But now no one can take this new apartment from me. I thank engineer Belkacem. God sent this man to rescue the city from disaster."

Pictures of Belkacem, widely known as “The Engineer,” his younger brother Saddam, a military commander also involved in the reconstruction effort, and their father, Khalifa, are plastered on billboards across Derna and the region.

Hussein Al-Mansouri, project manager for the “Two Thousand Apartments” complex in which Damdoum currently resides, says: “Since 2011, Libya has not witnessed major projects like this. I feel very happy and proud, and one day I will tell my children: I made this.”

The complex includes a new mosque, hospital, commercial center and schools. New roads and bridges were also built in Derna. Although many survivors have been provided with housing, others are still waiting.

Among them is Ezz El-Nasr Ebzio, a lecturer in marine sciences at the university. His wife, Salima, her mother, Mona, and all seven of their children, whose ages ranged from one to 11 years, drowned.

The family's home was severely damaged, but the authorities have not yet finished completely restoring it because Epzio also owns another intact apartment in one of the city's neighborhoods.

Epzio returns every day to his old house, which has turned into an empty shell, to check on his children’s belongings, which he left as they were, covered in dust.

He says: "This is my son Moaz's bicycle. He used to play with it every day. This is my daughter Fawzia's dress. She used to wear it whenever she went to a wedding, and even if I decided not to come to remember them, my feet would lead me here without me realizing."

To date, the bodies of his family members have not been found.

In the spacious new cemetery established for flood victims in Derna, most of the graves bear only numbers and no names, because the process of matching the DNA of survivors with the bodies has not yet been completed.

Damdoum says: “I go to the cemetery and try to guess where my family lies. This has burned my heart so much. Thank God I am patient, but I am still just waiting to read the Qur’an at their graves and say hello to them.”

Belkacem Haftar expanded the work of the Reconstruction Fund to include the city of Benghazi, the second largest city in Libya, and other areas under his father’s control.

Last year, the Libyan Parliament, based in the east of the country, allocated an additional amount of approximately $11 billion for it to spend over three years, in addition to the two billion dollars previously allocated to it for Derna.

Construction work in Benghazi included the construction of skyscrapers, hospitals, housing projects and the renovation of a football stadium that last year hosted a friendly match between Inter Milan and Atletico Madrid.

Officials spoke of transforming the city into a copy of "Dubai on the Mediterranean."

Belkacem told the BBC that he had accomplished more than any previous Libyan administration.

He added: "Libya went through Gaddafi's phase, forty years of neglect and poverty. The interim governments that came after Gaddafi and were based in Tripoli wasted a lot of money without providing anything tangible to the people. I never made promises to the people, but I provided them with what they needed."

International human rights organizations have accused, on several occasions, the authorities in eastern Libya and the Libyan Arab Armed Forces led by Khalifa Haftar of committing grave violations, including secret executions, arbitrary arrests, and enforced disappearances.

Al Haftar and the government based in Benghazi deny these accusations. Belkacem told the BBC that freedom of expression is fully guaranteed in eastern Libya.

Critics also say that the Haftar family follows a top-down approach to development with limited public participation in planning decisions, far from transparency.

“There is absolutely no accountability,” says Claudia Gazzini of the International Crisis Group. “We have never seen any financial statements for the Reconstruction Fund, even in terms of legal and public transfers of funds.”

But Belkacem confirms that the fund is subject to independent audit and that all contracts are concluded in accordance with high international standards.

In response to concerns about transparency, he said: “What we did in Derna was next to impossible. What matters to us is reality and what we achieve on the ground.”

He agreed to show the BBC the audit reports, but did not provide them despite repeated requests.

As for Jalal Harchaoui, an expert on Libyan affairs associated with the Royal United Services Institute in London, who spoke to some foreign partners who received construction contracts, he says that these companies are usually required to work alongside a private Libyan company indirectly linked to the Haftar family or other influential political figures.

He adds: “What these foreign companies say, apart from the official record, is that they carry out the bulk of the work, while the Libyan partner is often just an almost empty shell, under arrangements in which the money is often divided equally,” which indicates that the cost of many of these facilities, bridges and towers is exaggerated, reaching twice their real cost.

“This is a form of overpricing in an environment that completely lacks transparency, and there is no magic fairy falling from the sky to finance these reconstruction efforts. Everything is financed from Libya’s public wealth,” Harchaoui said.

Belkacem Haftar denies accusations of corruption in reconstruction projects.

He said that the reconstruction funds were disbursed through the Central Bank of Libya, which works for both the internationally recognized government in Tripoli in the west of the country and the government based in the city of Benghazi in the east.

“Haftar’s authorities used Derna as a demonstration model for what they were promoting in the rest of Libya,” Gazzini says.

International efforts to reunify the country included a proposal from Massad Boulos, the envoy of US President Donald Trump, to conclude a power-sharing agreement under which Saddam Haftar would be president of Libya.

In Derna, there are no plans to rebuild the two collapsed dams, so a repeat of a disaster of the same scale seems unlikely. But the possibility of future floods still exists.

Gazzini says that the authorities did not benefit from offers made by international experts on ways to reduce risks, such as creating floodplains along the valley that passes through the city.

She added: "I was expecting an integrated project to manage water flow, but that did not happen. The Libyan side was more responsive to the needs of the population and more interested in finding a quick solution to the devastation that befell the city."

Find out more

Short clips

End of short clips

Main news

Why are security partnerships on the rise in the MENA region?

Derna, rebuilt after devastating floods, becomes a showcase for Khalifa Haftar’s rule

Life sentences and 15 years in prison in the largest trial of Shiite clerics in Bahrain, and the Iranian Foreign Ministry condemns the sentences

We chose for you

Readers' preferences