Photo copyright: Reuters
Democrats confidently won the midterm elections in the United States, gaining control of both houses of Congress. For Donald Trump, who two years ago led Republicans to victory in the presidential and parliamentary elections, this is a serious blow to political influence within the party. Moreover, the president himself urged Americans to vote as if his name was on the ballot. The BBC tells how and why the Republicans were defeated amid rising prices and the war in Iran.
The Party Between Trump and Voters
In US midterm elections, the incumbent president's party almost always loses seats in the House of Representatives—this is one of the most consistent patterns in American politics.
In the vast majority of midterm elections, the president's party lost seats in the lower house of Congress, although there were exceptions to this rule.
If the president in the United States is elected for four years, then the House of Representatives is elected for two. The country's founding fathers conceived it as the most dependent part of the federal government on the will of voters, so that citizens could quickly respond to the actions of politicians and change the composition of legislators without waiting for the end of the presidential term. Therefore, every four years, elections to the House of Representatives coincide with the presidential elections, and mid-term elections take place between them.
Photo copyright MANDEL NGAN / AFP via Getty Images
Midterm elections often turn into a referendum on the performance of the current president: voters dissatisfied with his policies are given the opportunity to protest. Differences in turnout among supporters of the two parties also influence the outcome.
In the Senate, the president’s party also loses seats more often, but this pattern is less pronounced due to constitutional features - every two years, not the entire Senate, but about a third of its composition, is re-elected.
Before these midterm elections, Donald Trump asked supporters to vote as if his name was on the ballot.
Some analysts say that since the presidential election, Trump has convinced himself that he has the unconditional support of voters, and with it a mandate for change in the country. He had reason to think so: Trump won all seven swing states and received 312 electoral votes to Kamala Harris' 226.
End of Most Popular
But in the national vote, 49.8% of voters voted for Trump, while 48.3% voted for the Democratic candidate. There is a gulf between victory by a margin of one and a half points and public consent for radical changes.
This was subsequently confirmed by American political scientist George Edwards, who compared the election results with polls about specific administration decisions. He found that Americans as a whole did not perceive Trump's victory as approval of large-scale changes and did not want to give the president additional powers.
Expensive fuel: what voters were unhappy with
In the AP Voter Poll, conducted at the polling stations, about four in ten voters named the economy as the country's main problem, and three in ten named the state of democracy. Among everyday worries, voters highlighted prices for food and gasoline.
Photo copyrightAndres Kudacki/Getty Images
This extension will help if you have difficulties accessing the BBC Russian Service website.
Download extension
End of story Chrome browser extension - link
Gasoline, diesel fuel and gas prices have risen especially noticeably. The war with Iran has disrupted oil supplies through the Strait of Hormuz, and Americans are feeling the effects at the pump. Before the war began, a gallon of gasoline in the United States cost an average of $2.98. By October 26, a week before the election, the price had risen to $4.29—an increase of nearly 44%.
For Trump, who promised to curb inflation in 2024, this has become a major political problem. About six out of ten respondents attributed high prices primarily to his policies.
And about four in 10 said they voted in congressional elections to express disagreement with the president. Slightly less than two out of ten wanted to support him, and for another four out of ten, their attitude towards Trump did not influence their choice. At the same time, about seven in ten believed that Congress did not restrain the president enough.
The American media is trying to figure out what went wrong for the Republicans.
Donald Trump "puts personal loyalty above the candidate's ability to attract a wider range of voters" - which is why Republicans had to defend themselves even in those states where they initially had an advantage, writes Reuters.
Trump's support of Ken Paxton in Texas is a case in point. Paxton has been at the center of corruption scandals for years, and his political career has been marked by a series of official investigations, lawsuits and even impeachment proceedings.
In relation to Texas, another point is also important: the policies of the Republicans themselves could have led to today’s result. For decades, Republican state officials have lured companies with low taxes, more affordable housing and less regulation. Since 2015, more than 300 companies have moved their headquarters to the state. People who came with them included more university graduates than the average Texan, The Atlantic notes.
Over the decade, the share of adults in the state with at least a bachelor's degree rose from 28% to 35%. This group has increasingly voted Democratic in recent years. According to the publication, demographic changes created the conditions for victory, and dissatisfaction with prices and Paxton's candidacy helped Democrats take advantage of them now.
Democrats were also able to take advantage of Republican mistakes. The Washington Post notes that Democratic candidates have been advised to "campaign as if they were running for mayor": that is, in a situation where the Republican campaign revolves around President Trump, they need to focus on local issues, such as household spending. In addition, for districts that needed to be won from Republicans, the party leadership specifically sought out moderate candidates.
Trump bet on the wrong ones?
In the past two years, Donald Trump has enjoyed such freedom of action that Republican senators and congressmen considered it dangerous to object to him, not wanting to lose the president's support in the primaries.
As a result, before the midterm elections, many congressmen found themselves in a difficult situation: if you oppose Trump, you can lose the primaries, but if you support him in everything, you risk losing the elections.
image copyrightGetty Images
In these midterm elections, Trump personally endorsed Republican candidates in Texas, North Carolina, and South Carolina—all three lost.
For the first time since 1988, Texas elected a Democrat to the Senate: James Talarico defeated state Attorney General Ken Paxton, who received public support from Trump despite allegations of corruption. Moreover, Talarico won both in large cities and in some urban and suburban areas that previously elected Republicans.
In South Carolina, pediatrician Annie Andrews defeated Senator Darlene Graham. Darlene, 62, is the younger sister of the late Senator Lindsey Graham, co-author of the law on “hellish” US sanctions against Russian oil. After her brother's death, she was appointed to fill the vacated Senate seat, but she failed to win a new six-year term, although Trump personally supported her and visited the state twice in the final weeks of the campaign.
Democratic winner Annie Andrews became the first representative of this party in South Carolina in 28 years to defeat Republicans in the election. And at the same time the first woman elected to the Senate from South Carolina.
In North Carolina, former Gov. Roy Cooper defeated former Republican National Committee Chairman Michael Whatley.
For the first time since 1932, Democrats won the Senate election in Kansas, where Adam Hamilton defeated incumbent Senator Roger Marshall. In Ohio, Sherrod Brown, who once held a seat in the Senate, returns to the upper house of Congress: he defeated incumbent Republican Senator Jon Husted. The point was made by Josh Turek, who defeated Congresswoman Ashley Hinson in Iowa.
Democrats also defended two Republican-held seats: Georgia and New Hampshire.
Before the elections, the Republicans had 53 seats in the Senate, the Democratic bloc had 47, including two independent senators. With six seats won from Republicans, Democrats secured the majority.
Redrawing the district map did not help
In the House of Representatives, Democrats needed a net gain of just three seats. The most noticeable result came from Pennsylvania: four incumbent Republican congressmen lost there.
The redrawing of electoral districts - in the American political tradition this is called gerrymandering - did not help the Republicans either. In the United States, House district boundaries are usually redrawn once every ten years, following the census, although they have also been changed between censuses. But before the current elections, the scale of change was impressive.
It all started in Texas, where, at the call of Donald Trump, local Republicans redrawn district lines in hopes of gaining five additional seats in the House of Representatives. Each district elects one member, so if state boundaries are drawn differently, a party could win more seats even with the same number of votes.
In Texas, Republicans redrew the boundaries of five districts where Democrats previously won, hoping to gain five additional seats in the House of Representatives.
The meaning of this castling is well demonstrated by the 34th District of Texas, which stretches along the Gulf Coast: from Brownsville, on the border with Mexico, north to Corpus Christi. In the previous boundaries of this district, Trump himself beat Harris by 4.5 percentage points in the presidential election, but then, at the same time as the president, district residents voted for Democrat Vicente Gonzalez in the congressional elections. Hoping to take the seat from him, Republicans redrawn the district's boundaries: if votes for Trump were recounted in the presidential election, his margin would increase to about 10 percentage points within the current boundaries. But this did not help: Gonzalez won within new boundaries.
In total, nine states voted along redrawn district lines. In seven of them, the new map increased the chances of Republicans, and in two - California and Utah - the Democrats. At the same time, in California, the redrawing was initiated by the Democrats themselves in response to the actions of the Republicans in Texas, and in Utah the boundaries were determined by the court.
The Republicans' calculations also did not materialize in Florida, where they hoped to gain four additional seats, but Democrats won in at least three of the four districts they were counting on. For example, the 14th District around Tampa, Florida's third most populous city, added some areas that previously voted heavily Republican and removed the city of St. Petersburg. Despite this, Democratic Representative Kathy Castor won the district.
Redrawing district lines didn't work out the way Trump hoped. Initially, the new map seemed winning to the Republicans, but the problem was that Trump’s own results in 2024 were taken as a guide. The landmark turned out to be unreliable, writes AP.
Will the Republicans make it before the new year?
The current Congress remains in office until Jan. 3, 2027, leaving Republicans just a few work weeks to prepare for the next two years of Donald Trump's presidency without majority support in both chambers.
One of the Republicans' intentions is to raise the debt ceiling before Democrats have the opportunity to dictate terms. Trump wants to raise the limit by the end of the year so that in 2027 he does not have to go to the Democratic Congress for permission to new borrowings and discuss counterclaims. Republican Senator Kevin Cramer proposes to reach an agreement with the Democrats, and if they refuse, to include the increase in the budget package, which can be passed with a simple majority.
Trump also hopes to pass at least part of the SAVE America Act, a voter law. The president is pushing for voters to document proof of citizenship when registering to vote in federal elections and to show photo identification to vote, even though about 21 million adult American citizens do not have access to proof of citizenship.
How will this affect the war in Iran and aid to Ukraine?
In addition, the Republicans may have time to allocate money to the Pentagon before January to cover part of the costs of the war with Iran and to purchase ammunition to replace those spent. At the end of October, the Pentagon estimated the cost of the war at $47.1 billion.
According to the American Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), there is little time for the entire White House request to be adopted as a separate law. A more likely option would be to include some of the money, primarily for ammunition, in a broader defense spending bill. This option has already been proposed by Republican Congressman Rob Wittman. If the law is passed before January, the Pentagon will have funds for these purchases even after the change of majority.
In addition to Iran, the annual defense policy law will also affect Ukraine. At stake is the fate of $750 million for the American weapons procurement program for Kyiv.
image copyrightKevin Dietsch/Getty Images
Former CIA Director William Burns told the Washington Post, "This [election] result will encourage our allies." A year ago, Burns said, US partners feared Trump's return reflected a profound change in how Americans thought about their country and its place in the world. The results of this election, according to Burns, give reason to doubt that the change is so profound.
Brussels is more reserved about this: even before the vote, EU and NATO officials said they doubted how much even a major Democratic victory could limit Trump.
They still have to plan defenses without knowing which U.S. forces will remain in Europe and deal with the risk of new U.S. tariffs in trade negotiations.
On both issues, much still depends on the decisions of Donald Trump.
End of Subscribe to our social networks and newsletter
Download the new BBC World Service app!
When you first open the app, select "BBC News Russian Service" and receive notifications about important news, analysis, videos and podcasts.
Important: The new app is not available in the UK and US.
Find out more
Video playlist
End Video playlist




