Image credit: Ira L. Black/Corbis/MOHD RASFAN/Kristina Solovyova/POOL/AFP via Getty Images

The leaders of China, Russia and the United States are preparing for their first trilateral meeting, causing concern in Europe. Some saw this as reminiscent of the post-World War II period when the world was divided into spheres of influence.

On November 4, when Russian President Vladimir Putin and a group of school children visited an exhibition at the Moscow Manege near Red Square in Moscow, they stopped in front of a large sculpture. The sculpture depicts the three leaders at the Yalta Conference in February 1945: then British Prime Minister Winston Churchill, US President Franklin D Roosevelt, and Soviet leader Joseph Stalin.

Putin explained to the children: "They were the leaders of the three major powers at the time, and they came together to discuss how the world should be organized after the war."

Just the day before, the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Kremlin announced that they were negotiating for a meeting between Putin, US President Donald Trump, and Chinese President Xi Jinping on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Summit in Shenzhen from November 18 to 19. White House spokesperson Olivia Wales confirmed on Friday that the three-way meeting would take place.

When it was first reported in mid-October that the Kremlin proposed holding this meeting, the EU and Ukraine immediately expressed concern. This reminded many people of the meeting held by the leaders of the anti-Hittra alliance at the Yalta palace formerly owned by the Russian tsar on the coast of the Black Sea.

At the Yalta Conference, Stalin agreed to enter the war against Japan after defeating Germany in exchange for the other Allies accepting expanded Soviet influence in Eastern Europe. In addition, a secret agreement on East Asia gave the Soviet Union access to Japanese-controlled southern Sakhalin and the Kuril Islands, the restoration of a Soviet naval base in Port Arthur, China, and special economic rights in Manchuria.

Since then, in Eastern Europe, the word "Yalta" has often become synonymous with big countries secretly carving up spheres of influence in the world regardless of the interests of small countries, even if the countries involved in the divided territories have no right to interfere.

image copyrightGetty Images

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said: "I very much do not want a second, third or fourth Yalta conference, where the parties will just redivide their spheres of influence."

End of Hot Reading

"Following the Alaska summit, if things develop in the direction that Russian officials are currently suggesting, hoping to lead to a new Yalta conference, this will be Russia's second major diplomatic victory."

At the same time, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said that any discussion about ending the war in Ukraine must involve Europe.

"Europe must and wants to play a role in this process," he said.

"The key issues of the peace agreement, whether they are sanctions or the future security architecture, can only be resolved with the participation of us Europeans, and all participants know this."

"Unusual form"

The Wall Street Journal reports that Putin may indeed be hoping to drum up support to end the war in Ukraine on terms favorable to Russia. However, exactly what he hopes to discuss with Trump and Xi remains unclear.

Russian presidential assistant Yuri Ushakov said: "It is inevitable that the Ukrainian issue will be raised in some form."

But he added: "At the moment, there are only some preliminary ideas of what could be discussed at such a high level and in such an unusual format."

Trump denied that Ukraine was on the agenda and said: "We can meet to discuss nuclear weapons and nuclear disarmament."

Joseph Torigian, associate professor at American University in Washington, believes that China also does not want to participate in Ukraine negotiations that exclude Europe, because Beijing is doing its best to downplay the impression that China is supporting Russia in this war.

Although the Chinese elite has paid less and less attention to the EU in recent years, China still intends to maintain good relations with European countries because these countries are important trading partners.

However, Torigian pointed out that Beijing is also skeptical about nuclear weapons negotiations.

"They believe that because China's nuclear weapons program is relatively small, remaining opaque is one of its advantages," he said.

"Bringing peace"

Russia wants this meeting for obvious reasons: to exclude Europe from negotiations on Ukraine and to once again show the world that Moscow cannot be isolated on the international stage.

The appeal of the meeting to U.S. leaders was equally obvious.

"Trump is excited about this because of the grandeur and atmosphere of the meeting," Torigian said.

"He can tell a story to the outside world about how wonderful it is that these big countries can come together, and he is the first person to make this happen and is bringing peace to the world."

Soviet demands

For Beijing, however, the benefits of the meeting are far less clear.

"For the Chinese, Yalta is not a good memory," Torigian said.

At that time, Stalin successfully won the Soviet Union's special rights and interests in Manchuria, which made the Chinese extremely angry.

"Even after the Communists took power in China in 1949, Mao Zedong believed that all the demands made by the Soviet Union at Yalta, and the demands they continued to make thereafter, were a huge source of frustration," Torigian said.

These disputes were also part of the reasons for the subsequent breakup between China and the Soviet Union.

As for Eastern Europe, historians still debate the extent to which allowing the Soviet Union to expand its sphere of influence was simply an acceptance of an inevitable reality.

Because by February 1945, the Soviet Red Army had occupied large areas of Romania, Bulgaria, Poland, Hungary, and Czechoslovakia.

But as of today, Russian forces do not even fully control the territories in eastern Ukraine that the Kremlin claims as Russian. Moreover, unlike 1945, only one of the three leaders who may attend the summit this time is directly involved in the war.

international reputation

Torigian said that Russia is also the only country among the three countries that still intends to clearly divide the world into different spheres of influence.

Although the National Security Strategy adopted by the Trump administration describes the Western Hemisphere as the U.S. sphere of influence, the United States is not ready to give up its support for Taiwan. And China’s influence in Latin America remains important to Beijing.

Russia sees itself as a superpower on par with the United States and China, and Chinese official statements often describe Russia as an equal partner.

But Marcin Kaczmarski of the University of Glasgow said: "Privately, neither China experts nor the Chinese leadership believe that Russia is a great power comparable to China."

He pointed out: "The only country that China's leadership and elites truly believe is on an equal footing with China is the United States."

Kaczmarski said the tripartite summit could help boost Beijing's international prestige and project Xi Jinping as a global political leader that leaders of other major powers come to meet in person.

image copyrightAFP

However, after the Republican Party lost the midterm elections in the U.S. Congress, Trump’s position on the international stage has become less stable.

The question, Kaczmarski said, is whether China wants to enhance Trump's international standing.

"I'm still very unsure about whether the meeting itself will happen," he added.

In the 2000s, during his visit to Eastern Europe, then-US President George W Bush repeatedly described the Yalta Agreement as an evil act in history.

According to the New York Times, these remarks were specifically directed at Putin and were intended to tell him that Russia had no right to interfere in the affairs of neighboring countries and must apologize for the Soviet Union's actions back then.

In 2002, George W. Bush declared in Vilnius, the capital of Lithuania: "No more Yalta Conference."

Nearly 25 years later, if Putin can successfully bring the leaders of the United States and China together in anything even remotely resembling Yalta, it will be a symbolic victory for him, even if the conference itself yields no concrete results.

This article was originally written in English. We used artificial intelligence to assist in translation and was reviewed by BBC journalists before publication. Learn more about how we use artificial intelligence.

Explore more

More short films

More short films end

The White House confirms that Trump, Xi Jinping and Putin will hold a historic tripartite meeting during APEC in Shenzhen

Before the APEC summit, a US think tank analyzes the details and limits of Sino-Russian military-industrial cooperation under "technological nationalism"

Putin proposes "trilateral talks" between China, the United States and Russia: Trump responds, Beijing remains silent, and Kiev opposes

Four months before APEC, China’s Shenzhen subway suddenly tightened security checks, causing public complaints

Zelensky: The United States offers Ukraine to give up Donbass in exchange for joining NATO

Trump-Xi Summit: Unspoken issues may be more important

headlines

APEC Shenzhen Summit Preview: The trilateral talks between the United States, China and Russia are in suspense, and Takaichi Sanae faces the test of "handshake"

What will the historic meeting between Xi Jinping, Trump and Putin mean to the world?

French presidential election: Five-time Olympic judo champion unexpectedly joins the race, stirring up the election

Special recommendation

Popular content