image copyrightGetty Images

The dispute in Texas over a seat in the United States Senate may prove crucial in determining which party will control Congress next year. Although this is an important award in itself, for both parties it represents much more than that.

For Democrats, the losing streak in state elections in Texas stretches back more than three decades. In the second most populous state in the United States, liberals have remained out of power for an entire generation.

However, polls suggest that Democratic Senate candidate James Talarico, 37, could be about to buck that trend and return Texas a seat in the Upper House for the first time since 1988.

That would be an ideal scenario for Democrats and a possible nightmare for Republicans.

"If the Democrats pull it off, I think it will cause deep soul-searching and great psychological damage to the Republican Party in Texas and across the country," said Brendan Steinhauser, a Texas-based Republican campaign strategist.

All that is at stake helps explain why this Senate race has ballooned to become the most expensive in American history, with total spending exceeding $500 million.

Talarico, the Democratic bet

Just a year ago, James Talarico was a relatively unknown Democrat in Texas. Today he is one of the main political protagonists of the state.

A few days ago, at the Fiesta Center in Lubbock, Texas, the line to see the soft-spoken former teacher, who studied to be a pastor, stretched around the building and across the large parking lot to a crowded road.

End of Most read

The visit of a major Democratic candidate on the eve of an election is unusual for this dusty city of about 250,000 people, which voted overwhelmingly for President Donald Trump two years ago.

"It's just amazing to see," said Aaron Gonzalez, chairman of the Hockley County Democratic Party, which borders Lubbock. "This time it's different."

image source, Reuters

All the news you need is on BBC World Service

Download it here

End of Ad app

When Talarico took the stage and addressed some 3,000 supporters, while another 1,000 followed his speech over loudspeakers installed outside, many Democrats across the country recognized a familiar message, albeit with a Texan stamp.

The candidate attacked the conservative political establishment, which he accused of being insensitive to the economic difficulties of ordinary Americans.

He condemned the corrosive influence of big economic interests in politics and promised to promote a "broad anti-corruption agenda" in the Senate.

"Texans are ready for change (...). We are tired of extremism and corruption. We are tired of the politics of division and we are ready for something new," he said.

The slogan for their final two weeks of campaigning – "clear eyes, full hearts, can't lose" – was taken from Friday Night Lights, a popular television series from the early 2000s about a combative high school football team in a small Texas town.

His music playlist focuses primarily on Texas country music with his signature sound.

He celebrates Texas breakfast tacos, quotes legendary singer-songwriter Lyle Lovett, and frequently mentions that his roots in the state go back eight generations.

Among the Lubbock audience, Texas Tech University student Andrew Robinson was pleased with what he heard.

But the 26-year-old's optimism was tempered by a lifetime of watching Democrats try, unsuccessfully, to get a foothold in the state.

"A victory for Talarico would mean a lot," he said. "I haven't had much desire to stay in Texas. And if the government changed, it might give me a reason."

The concern of Republicans

For Republicans, a Democratic victory in Texas would have a very different meaning.

Around the same time Talarico was addressing supporters at the Fiesta Center, Donald Trump was a few miles away, in a venue twice the size, alongside Republican Senate candidate Ken Paxton.

"If you come out and vote, we're going to have a tremendous victory in Texas," the president told the crowd.

Trump's visit to Lubbock, a traditionally Republican city, suggests the party is concerned about voter turnout even in the most conservative parts of the state.

This concern has been shared by other Texas Republicans.

"Understand that we could lose Texas," Texas Senator Ted Cruz said on his podcast on Friday. "Democrats are mobilizing many, many more voters than Republicans."

Don Huffines, who is running for state chief financial officer, issued an even more dire warning. "Texas is the base of the Republican Party in the United States," he published in X.

"When the foundation breaks, everything falls apart. If we lose Texas, we lose America."

For weeks, party leaders have been warning that a Democratic advance in the state of Texas could have dire consequences.

They fear that a Talarico victory will encourage more local Democrats to run for state and federal offices.

Higher quality candidates with more funding could generate a domino effect similar to the Democratic advance seen in other southern states, such as Georgia, North Carolina and Virginia.

"I think it's pretty clear that Republicans, especially candidates, consultants, operatives and other active members of the party, see this as a real threat," Steinhauser said.

"Gone are the days of downplaying this and saying Texas would never go Democratic," he added.

"Perfect storm"

For the Texas Senate race to reach the point where recent polls suggest Talarico has a narrow but stable lead, it took an unusual confluence of events and political dynamics.

A "perfect storm," in Steinhauser's words.

"Everything that could go right for Democrats is going right and everything that could go wrong for Republicans is going wrong," he explained.

But it is also a whirlwind that, to a large extent, has been sown over the last year by Trump himself.

The national outlook for Republicans is very adverse.

Voters are frustrated by high consumer prices, including the price of gasoline, and largely blame Trump's tariff policies and the war with Iran.

Furthermore, political corruption has become an issue of growing concern.

In a recent Cook Political Report poll, Democrats, independents and many Republicans identified "greedy billionaires and corporations" and politicians seeking "personal gain" as responsible.

The specific problems in Texas have also contributed to creating a hostile climate for the party in power.

Polls and recent special elections in Texas indicate that Latino voters, many of whom voted for Trump to help him win the White House in 2024, have been dissatisfied with the administration's immigration enforcement policies.

Latinos make up nearly a third of the state's population and, in more than a week of early voting in Texas, have been casting their ballots in historically high numbers.

The construction of data centers, which Texas Republicans touted as a welcome investment for the state, has drawn widespread criticism, particularly in rural areas that have traditionally been solidly conservative.

Republican Texas Governor Greg Abbott, in the midst of a tight re-election race, recently announced a one-year moratorium on the construction of AI facilities in the state, reflecting how quickly the issue has become a political liability.

"This is bad for Republicans," a Texas political strategist who asked to remain anonymous told the BBC. "Right now, we are asking too much of the electorate for us to remain in charge."

Paxton's problems

Added to that is the burden that Republican candidate Ken Paxton adds to the campaign.

This year he defeated long-serving Senator John Cornyn in a particularly close primary.

The 63-year-old Republican managed to portray Cornyn, 74, as too old and out of touch with Texas conservatives.

In addition, he received a last-minute boost when, just days before beating Cornyn in the primary runoff, he obtained Trump's endorsement.

"Ken Paxton has been through a lot, in many cases very unfairly, but he is a fighter and knows how to win," Trump wrote in Truth Social. "Our country needs fighters and also loyalty to the cause of greatness."

The "a lot" to which the president was referring includes a federal indictment for alleged financial fraud filed against Paxton in 2015, which was later withdrawn, as well as the impeachment trial initiated in 2023 by the Texas House of Representatives, controlled by Republicans, on accusations of corruption, bribery and abuse of power.

The Texas Senate then acquitted Paxton after Trump intervened to pressure the state's Republican leaders.

All of this has meant that Paxton has plenty of critics — and enemies — in Texas, even within his own party.

Talarico, on the other hand, has proven to be an effective candidate.

The state lawmaker defeated a well-known opponent, Dallas Congresswoman Jasmine Crockett, in the Democratic primary.

Since reaching the nomination, he has maintained his lead in the polls despite a relentless avalanche of negative publicity, much of it funded by the world's richest man, Elon Musk.

Musk, whose company SpaceX is based in Texas, has alone invested more than $170 million in the Republican campaign. Trump's MAGA Inc. committee has contributed $40 million.

Although Paxton has proven to be an ineffective fundraiser, money spent by outside groups in support of his candidacy has flooded the state's television and radio airwaves.

It has even been extended to broadcasts of sporting events of Texan teams followed throughout the country.

Those groups have attacked Talarico for past statements he made in support of transgender people, for calling "radicalized white men" a domestic terrorism threat and for his criticism of the fossil fuel and beef industries, two sectors with great influence in the state.

Talarico has distanced himself from some of those comments, arguing that many were taken out of context and that some were "inappropriate," "deliberately provocative," or simply "embarrassing."

A million dollar campaign

Meanwhile, the Democrat has proven to be a successful fundraiser, racking up more than $140 million in donations over the course of his campaign and setting a three-month fundraising record for a Senate candidate.

The funding has allowed Talarico to counterattack Paxton, highlighting his past controversies and fending off Republican attacks.

He frequently draws on his religious upbringing as the grandson of a Southern Baptist preacher who spent time in a seminary and peppers his speeches with biblical references.

There is one passage in particular that Talarico has given a certain preference to lately: the well-known Old Testament confrontation between the fighter David and the giant Goliath.

"We are facing our own Goliaths," he said in Lubbock.

"The mega-donor billionaires, the corporate special interests, the entire Washington DC elite - their power is real, but so is ours."

But the power of Texas Democrats has been overestimated in the past.

In 2018, Congressman Beto O'Rourke posted historic fundraising numbers, attracted widespread national attention, and ultimately lost to Texas Senator Cruz by just over 2%.

Talarico's lead in the polls, while stable, remains close to the margin of error in most polls.

Additionally, last-minute Republican appeals, as well as Trump's repeated visits to the campaign trail, could drive greater turnout among conservative voters on Election Day, erasing any advantage Democrats have gained in early voting.

Inside the tiny Democratic Party office at a Talarico rally in Amarillo, retired teacher Terri Mills listens to the candidate's stump speech.

Despite acknowledging decades of Democratic failures and false hopes, he says this time he allows himself to once again believe in a victory for his party.

"I've been excited before, you know," he said. "But I feel like this time it's a little different."

This article was originally written in English and we used an artificial intelligence tool to translate it. A BBC journalist reviewed the text before publication. Learn more about how we use AI.

Discover more

Video

End of Video

Top news

8 charts that show why the midterm elections come at a bad time for Trump and what's at stake

Jesús de Miguel, Spanish Tenerife footballer, dies after a collision on the playing field with the rival goalkeeper

The mother in Chile who was forced to wait for her baby to die in her womb and now a historic ruling grants her millionaire compensation

Don't miss it

Most popular readings